Pit Barrel vs Weber Smokey Mountain
Pit Barrel Cooker
vs
Weber Smokey Mountain
Low-and-slow vs fast-and-hot. Modify-and-tinker vs ready-out-of-the-box. Here is the honest, category-by-category breakdown so you can pick the right one for your backyard.
The Weber Smokey Mountain (WSM) is one of the most popular charcoal smokers ever made and the default recommendation in many BBQ forums. The Pit Barrel Cooker is the most popular vertical drum smoker in America. Both produce excellent BBQ. They are very different cookers built around different philosophies, and the right choice depends on what kind of BBQ experience you want. This honest comparison breaks down where each cooker wins so you can make an informed decision.
01 / Quick VerdictThe Short Version
Choose the Pit Barrel Cooker if you want simpler operation, faster cook times, no water pan to manage, and a cooker that comes ready to use with no learning curve. Choose the Weber Smokey Mountain if you prefer the traditional bullet smoker design, want maximum customization potential through aftermarket modifications, and enjoy the process of slow temperature management.
Same BBQ. Half The Hours.
02 / PhilosophyCooking Philosophy
The Weber Smokey Mountain is a traditional low-and-slow smoker designed to cook at 225 degrees Fahrenheit for 8 to 12 hours per cook. The included water pan stabilizes temperature and adds humidity. The WSM rewards careful temperature management and can be modified extensively with aftermarket parts. The Pit Barrel Cooker takes the opposite approach, cooking fast and hot at 275 to 310 degrees with no water pan and no temperature dial. The vertical hanging design means food cooks evenly without rotation, and the cooker holds steady temperature without intervention.
03 / The ClockCook Times
The Pit Barrel Cooker finishes BBQ in roughly half the time of the WSM. Ribs that take 5 to 6 hours on the WSM finish in 3 to 4 hours on the Pit Barrel. Pork shoulders that take 12 hours on the WSM finish in 6 to 7 on the Pit Barrel. A full brisket that takes 14 hours on the WSM cooks within 6 to 7 hours on the Pit Barrel. The faster cook times do not sacrifice tenderness or flavor, they simply use a different cooking approach that delivers comparable BBQ in less time. For weeknight cooking and weekend efficiency, the Pit Barrel wins.
04 / The Learning CurveSetup And Learning Curve
The Pit Barrel Cooker is ready to use out of the box with no seasoning required. Setup takes about 10 minutes and there is essentially no learning curve. The Weber Smokey Mountain requires some assembly and benefits from break-in cooks to learn how the cooker holds temperature. WSM owners typically modify their cookers with gaskets, hinges, and aftermarket doors to address common issues. The Pit Barrel works as designed without modifications.
05 / CapacityCapacity And Footprint
The 18.5 inch Pit Barrel Cooker holds 8 racks of ribs hanging vertically, more than most WSM owners can fit even with hanging modifications. The 22.5 inch WSM has more total grate area but uses two flat grates rather than vertical hanging, limiting how easily it handles ribs and whole birds. Both cookers have similar footprints, but the Pit Barrel's hanging design uses vertical space more efficiently.
Once you light it, you walk away.
06 / OperationOperation And Maintenance
The Pit Barrel Cooker has no water pan, no removable middle section, and no door to gasket. Once you light it, you walk away. The WSM has a water pan that needs to be filled before each cook and tends to crust over with grease, a side door that often requires aftermarket gaskets to seal properly, and a three-section design that complicates moving the cooker between cooks. The Pit Barrel is simpler to use, simpler to clean, and simpler to maintain over many years.
07 / Real FireReal Fire On Both, Different Experiences
Both cookers burn real charcoal and produce authentic BBQ flavor that pellet grills cannot replicate. The WSM uses a Minion method to extend burns to 12 hours or more by lighting only a portion of the charcoal at start. The Pit Barrel uses a different lighting method optimized for the higher temperature fast and hot cooking style. Both produce excellent BBQ flavor with no additional wood required, though both accept wood chunks for extra smoke. The hanging system on the Pit Barrel produces slightly different bark and flavor due to the vertical orientation and direct fat dripping.
The 1980s design legacy. The WSM dates back to the 1980s and has been updated only modestly. Most owners spend $200 or more on aftermarket modifications (gaskets, hinges, replacement doors, controllers) to address well-documented issues. The Pit Barrel was designed without those issues, so no modifications are required to perform reliably.
08 / ValuePrice And Value
The Pit Barrel Cooker is typically priced similar to or below the WSM at comparable sizes. Both represent strong value compared to pellet grills, kamados, and offset smokers. WSM owners typically spend additional money on aftermarket parts including gaskets, hinges, doors, and temperature controllers, which adds to total cost over time. The Pit Barrel works as designed without modifications, making total ownership cost typically lower over the long term.
09 / VersatilityVersatility
Both cookers handle ribs, brisket, pork shoulder, chicken, turkey, and other classics. The Pit Barrel's vertical hanging design gives it an advantage for ribs, whole poultry, and jerky where vertical orientation produces better results. The WSM's flat grates give it an advantage for some specific cooks where you want to position multiple items at different distances from the heat. Both can grill on the included grate after the smoke is finished.
10 / The VerdictWhich Should You Buy?
Choose the Pit Barrel Cooker if you want real BBQ in less time without learning curve or constant fiddling. Choose the WSM if you enjoy the traditional smoker experience, prefer low and slow cooking, and want a cooker you can modify extensively over time. For most backyard cooks who want great BBQ without complexity, the Pit Barrel is the simpler and more reliable choice and will produce great food on day one.
See Our Complete
Cooker Lineup.
Real charcoal. Real BBQ. In half the time. Without the mods.
Shop The Lineup →